Western Digital Purple vs Seagate Surveillance HDD

Both lines are on Synology's and QNAP's official compatibility lists — this is not a "which works" question, but a "which fits your machine and workload" one. Everything below is read from the vendors' own HCLs, refreshed daily.

Western Digital Purple Surveillance 442NAS models up to 14TB · 38 part numbers
VS
Seagate Surveillance HDD Surveillance 378NAS models up to 6TB · 10 part numbers

Western Digital Purple prices  Seagate Surveillance HDD prices 

Head-to-head on the official list

Western Digital PurpleSeagate Surveillance HDD
Listed on official HCLs 442 models ✓ 378 models
Largest listed capacity 14 TB ✓ 6 TB
Smallest listed capacity 1 TB 1 TB
Part numbers on list 38 ✓ 10
Product line Surveillance Surveillance

Which should you buy?

Coverage-wise, Western Digital Purple appears on more NAS machines (442 vs 378) — for an older or unusual model that margin can matter. Within the same tier, the honest answer is: pick the cheaper part number at your target capacity, then verify it on your exact model's page.

Both lines overlap on 324 NAS models — if yours is one of them, either drive is officially supported.

Popular part numbers (most-listed 12 of 38 / 10)

Western Digital Purple

Seagate Surveillance HDD

NAS models that list both lines

These machines officially support both Western Digital Purple and Seagate Surveillance HDD — your real decision is workload and price, not compatibility.

QNAP HS-251Full HCL →QNAP HS-251+Full HCL →QNAP TAS-168Full HCL →QNAP TAS-268Full HCL →QNAP TS-1231XUFull HCL →QNAP TS-1231XU-RPFull HCL →QNAP TS-1232PXU-RPFull HCL →QNAP TS-1232XUFull HCL →QNAP TS-1232XU-RPFull HCL →QNAP TS-1253DU-RPFull HCL →QNAP TS-1253UFull HCL →QNAP TS-1253U-RPFull HCL →Synology DS1010+Full HCL →Synology DS1019+Full HCL →Synology DS110+Full HCL →Synology DS110jFull HCL →Synology DS111Full HCL →Synology DS112Full HCL →Synology DS112+Full HCL →Synology DS112jFull HCL →Synology DS114Full HCL →Synology DS115Full HCL →Synology DS115jFull HCL →Synology DS116Full HCL →Synology DS118Full HCL →Synology DS119jFull HCL →Synology DS120jFull HCL →Synology DS1511+Full HCL →Synology DS1512+Full HCL →Synology DS1513+Full HCL →Synology DS1515Full HCL →Synology DS1515+Full HCL →Synology DS1517Full HCL →Synology DS1517+Full HCL →Synology DS1618+Full HCL →Synology DS1812+Full HCL →